The Orcs were structured differently, with the main force gathered directly under the Warchief, and a separate command of missile troops.
Most of the Orcs are ‘average’ quality and ‘Tribal’ type, except the one unit I upgraded and the bodyguard, who are veteran, and the Trolls, who are ‘unpredictable’ quality (you roll every time you have to test on quality) and ‘fanatic’ type.
Before the Battle
Fantasy Warrior has quite an extensive set of events that happen before the battle. That may sound like it would get in the way of the actual gaming bit, but I kinda like it as it sets things up nicely and gives some great context and character, rather than just deploy and get bashing.
As Orcs perform better in ‘bad light’, the archery command scouted. The Dwarves didn’t scout as they are just as good during the day or night, so it mattered less to them. With a good dice roll, the Orcs outmanoeuvred the Dwarves so chose to start the battle at nightfall.
You can have a command ‘scout’. If it goes well, you can have some control over the time of the battle. This is important as certain races perform better or worse in darkness (something I’ve never seen in any other ruleset). If it goes really well you outmanoeuvre your opponent and completely control the time and place. However commands that scout start out the battle at a disadvantage, behind the main force and disorganised.
This game comes with a need for counters (YMMV), which can be downloaded here. One of them keeps track of the time! If either you or your opponent are affected by bad light, it makes scouting more important, and adds an interesting time pressure to your strategy.
Both sides decided to make Boasts. The Dwarf Warchief boasted “I will stay upon this spot like a rock!”, while the Orc Warchief promised his troops that they “shall destroy the enemy by sunrise!”.
Warchiefs can make boasts before the battle. If they still hold true when you have to make Command Tests later in the battle (usually caused when you lose a character or leader), you get a bonus - if they don’t…
The Orcs also decided to Read the Omens. A risky move, as a bad roll could work against them, and they had no soothsayers to add bonuses to the roll (yes, you can include them in your list, but if you lose them the omens automatically turn bad). The Orcs rolled a 4, the Omens were good!
With the pre-battle shenanigans complete, the two sites deployed, 24” apart. The Dwarves formed a solid line, with both commands on ‘Hold’ orders. Their plan was simple, hold the line against whatever reached them after the crossbows had thinned them out.
The Orc Warchief deployed his command on ‘Attack’ orders, with the trolls in the centre, flanked by the two Orc Warbands (the ‘Hands’ and ‘Moons’), and the Warchief and his bodyguard behind as a reserve. The Orc archers and ballista, having scouted, had to deploy behind, on ‘Hold’ orders and ‘Disorganised’. The Orc plan was also simple, throw everything possible at the centre of the dwarf line, Trolls first. But they would also need to get new orders to the archers.
TURN 1
Each turn follows the same order:
1 Make Threats
2 Shoot
3 Move
4 Combat
5 Issue New Orders
6 Influence (basically rallying)
7 Command Test (if needed)
Magic can occur at any time, including the pre-battle stage, as there are spells to influence scouting and the time of the battle.
The time dial
No one was in range to shoot or issue any threats. The Orc Warchief’s Battle advanced, with the trolls taking the lead. He also sent new ‘Oppose’ orders (flexible orders allowing movement and shooting, but not combat) to his Battle Leader using a Courier (a trained messenger. You can also use any rank and file soldier, but there is less chance of the new order getting through on time or even correctly). The Battle Leader rolled high and the order was immediately accepted.
"You want us to do what now?"
The Dwarf wizard now opened up hostilities in earnest, striking the trolls with a magical Blast, rolling 4 dice for damage, and using up 12 of his magic points (it should have only been 6 - 2 points for the range and 1 for each die of attacks, but rolling double or triples increased the cost accordingly, if I’d rolled a triple, that would have been the end of the wizard as it would have exceeded his available points!) . The damage rolls resulted in 3 ‘kills’. Trolls get a save, but failed one, resulting in one less Troll. Having taken more than 25% casualties they had to take a casualty test, which resulted in the remaining Troll going into ‘Bloodlust’ (oops!).
Dwarves 'Blackening the Skies'
The Dwarf crossbows shot at the moon clan, ‘Blackening the Skies’ (archers have six volleys available per battle, and can choose to shoot more of them off in one turn to maximise impact). 7 hits resulted in two Orc casualties. The Giant Crossbow did the same against the Hand clan, again causing two casualties.
The Orc Ballista attempted the same in return but with no results (the Orc Archers remained out of range).
Twang!!!
I got the turn order badly wrong here, the Dwarf Crossbows shouldn’t have been able to shoot as movement follows shooting, not the other way around)
TURN 2
The Dwarf Archery continued to take a toll, with both the crossbows and the giant crossbow causing one casualty each (normal shooting this time). The Orc ballista managed to get a hit this time but it was turned by the Dwarves’ heavy armour.
TURN 3
The Crossbows blackened the sky again, this time causing 6 casualties and killing the unit’s leader! Now down to just three, they took a Casualty Test and ended up ‘Shaken’ but still in the battle. The giant crossbow took another casualty off the Hand clan and the Orc Ballista did... nothing.
Things got interesting now as the remaining Troll crashed into the Dwarf axes. In its bloodlust fuelled frenzy it took down two dwarves, but they held their ground and chopped it down in return. Having taken casualties the dwarves had to take a Casualty Test but were OK (although if they’d rolled one higher they would have gone into Bloodlust themselves, possibly risking the Dwarves solid line and exposing their flank).
"They've brought a Troll..."
As we all know, Orcs prefer to work for a greater evil...
Photo without the cat
TURN 4
The remains of the Moon Clan tried to Threaten the Dwarf Warriors to its front (Threatening gives you a chance to reduce your oppositions morale, or even make the run-away, before fighting them; I didn’t think the Moons Clan stood much of a chance, but wanted to see how it went). Their threats and insults had, unsurprisingly, no effect of the stoic dwarves, but the bearded ones clashing of axes against shields (disciplined troops can’t initiate a threat, but can respond to one) was enough to persuade the Moons that they had urgent business elsewhere as they routed!
"Look how threatening we are!"
The crossbows (big and little) held their remaining volley of arrows for another opportunity. The Orc archers were finally in range but were useless, and the ballista used it’s last volley to no effect. The orc wizard was slightly more effective, causing three casualties on the dwarf axes with a Blast, using 12 magic points for an attack on five dice (just like the dwarf wizard, he rolled a double).
The Evil Overlord encourages his troops
The Orc Warchief sent new orders to his battle leader, telling them to attack. The order was accepted from the courier OK (but only just).
TURN 5
Time is running out for the Orc Warchief's Boast
The Hand Clan and Dwarf Axes hurled insults back and forth but to no effect on either side.
"Your Father was a hamster and your Mother smelled of Elderberries!"
The crossbows launched their final volley against the Orc archers, scoring 3 casualties and routing them! The giant crossbow launched its final volley against the Hand Clan but with no success. Both sides now had no archery left.
The Dwarf Battle leaders both joined their warriors in time to bolster them, before the Hands charged into the Dwarf axes. While the Dwarf WIzard, who had regained some magic points by resting attempted another Blast against the Orc Warchief’s bodyguard, causing two casualties (he rolled another double, leaving himself just one magic point).
Barbecued Orc Bodyguard
The combat between the Hand Clan and the Dwarf axes resulted in one casualty to the dwarves and one to the Hands, but with both side passing their casualty tests OK.
TURN 6
Last chance before sunrise
If the Orcs couldn’t destroy the enemy by the end of this turn their boast would fail. They couldn’t get enough units into combat to achieve it by brute force, but if they could rout or destroy at least one Dwarf Battle Leader, there was always the small chance of a catastrophic series of failed Command Tests!
Taking a chance, the Warchief and his bodyguard threatened the Dwarf Warriors, but with no success. The counter threat however saw an appalling dice throw from the Orcs, and the bodyguard and Warchief fled the field!
Seeing his leader running, the Battle Chief attempted to regain some honour by charging the crossbows with the courier, causing one casualty and leaving the crossbows Shaken. The Hands now looked like the Orcs' remaining chance, but they only caused 2 casualties for the Dwarves 4 and ended up Shaken themselves.
Desperate Times...
The Hands and Dwarf axes remain locked in combat
Having lost their Warchief, the Orcs now faced a Command Test (Taken by every Command and Individual character in the army). Their Boast still held (just), giving +1 to the roll, and the omens were still good (!), another +1. But the routed Warchief gave them a minus three. Both remaining commands rolled one…
It was all over, as the Orcs fled back from whence they came!
"Run away!"
CONCLUSIONS
I rather enjoyed that!
Having a fairly extensive set of actions before anything hits the table might be considered a bad idea normally, but it was all resolved quickly added a lot of character and context to the game and, most importantly directly impacted on it - making boasts or reading the omens isn’t just an isolated action, you have to structure your strategy around them. I played this out solo, but I can imagine it being rather fun making your boasts and reading the omens in character!
Scouting also has a genuine role, especially if you need to avoid bad light. I do recall that scouting success in WFB 3rd edition could also allow flank marches which might be fun to add. The whole concept of bad light, and of there being a time pressure to the game as a result, is also something that I really can’t recall finding anywhere else. I’ve occasionally come across rules for darkness, but they generally treat everyone the same and just seem to reduce ranges but this is something different and actively encourages scouting as well. My only reservation is that the day and night are rather short on the dial, only 6 spaces, so with armies deploying 24” apart and your average infantry unit moving 6”, they appear to be spending anything up to 8 hours just getting across the battlefield! I think I may play it as only one change in light is allowed, so the time dial is just measuring how long you have left until that change happens.
Leaders being leaders is an interesting difference to WFB. They can bolster the fighting strength of a unit (but not massively), but being in a unit hamper their ability to command and receive new orders.
Again, the ability to threaten units before attacking really adds character, and as it turned out made a huge difference! Like so much of the game though it’s a balance of risk and reward (and one that encourages proper units with standards and musicians, which is never a bad thing) - it panned out poorly for the Orcs this time, although I will admit I took some big risks, partly because it felt suitably ‘Orcy’ but also because I wanted to see what would happen.
I really like the archery rules. Having limited volleys means making tough choices about how and when to employ your shooting (a situation that would be familiar to any War of the Roses general). ‘Blackening the Skies’ is a great concept, do you measure out your volleys to support units throughout the game? Or expend it all in one massive attempt to shatter a threatening unit?
Magic use was a bit limited in the game, with both wizards only using one spell, but that was partly because my ipad with the main rules on ran out of battery part way through so I couldn’t look more up! The basic concept works though. There’s only one level of wizard, but you pay points based on how many magic points you take, and they’re expensive! So unless you are going to invest stupid amounts of points in magic you’re going to be using it sparingly and trying to pick that crucial moment that will make a difference. I like that you can use spells at any point (even in the pre-battle scouting phase for example).
I’ve read some reviews that have described the game’s combat phases as dull, but I don’t see them as any more so that Warhammer, or Dragon Rampant or most other games, it’s just mechanics and they work fine, leaving room for the interesting stuff.
Overall it felt like a game where you were having to weigh up the pros and cons of each action carefully, not relying on special rules and uber elites. Is it worth the risk of reading the runes or threatening that enemy unit? Should your Battle Leader join that unit that's about to be charged, or is there a chance he may need to receive new orders from the Warchief soon? Is now the time to use up most of your magic points and how big is the risk of your wizard expiring if it goes wrong?
So, enjoyed it and definitely up for another go. The Orcs were hampered by their archers being delayed by scouting, so they need a better solution, and I need a wizard. Oh, better do those bases too!
